IMO 2nd base needs to be filled by Rojas or Pitre. I doubt Voit or Stafura make it out of camp since they haven’t played AAA yet. If Baty is on the team he just needs to be a bench guy. I think Bo will opt in. Sign Sato for 1st.
Rojas has nearly 2,000 plate appearances in the minor leagues. (Carson Benge had only a little more than 1,100 in college and the minor leages.) I say we give Jefferson the first crack at 2B. We can figure out Baty (who had more tan 1,500 PA in the minors and almost as many for the Mets) later.
"When that poor defense was combined with his .620 OPS, Semien became unplayable, although he continued to get regular playing time despite his poor performance. " Quite so. The question is why did they continue to trot him out? We're told that both Stearns and Green are very smart guys. Are they? I think Rojas or Pitre should get a full shot, just like Benge and Ewing did. Keep them in even if they don't hit right away. Regarding Baty, it's very hard to know how much playing all over the place affected his hitting. I like Soto at DH, at least part of the time. If I were Stearns I'd also approach him about first base.
My question relates to the extent that the defensive metrics at 2B are tied to those at SS. In 2025 Seager had excellent numbers. In 2026 the NYM were ranked 27th at SS. I’d suggest there an infield issue at 1B, 2B, and SS for the Mets and inevitably Semien numbers can’t be isolated from the crummy numbers on either side of him. There was a broad generalized failure defensively and Semien contributed to that was was impacted by that.
The problem is both the Mets and Semien believe he's still a power hitter, capable of slugging 25+ home runs. The number of fly balls that were caught well in front of the warning track, clearly said otherwise. Until the Mets and Marcus recognize that he's not that guy anymore and just focuses on making hard contact, the better off they'll both be. Unless he decides to pull a Cuddyer, they're stuck with each other for two more years. That being said, I think it would be wise for Andy Green to have a heart to heart talk with him about what type of ballplayer he is and wants to be, at this point in his career.
I was always a Semien fan and liked his performance in Oakland. Naturally the Mets got him as career was waning and he didn't do much. IN the last 2 months was he trying to hit fly balls all the time? Automatic outs. He never seemed to hit sharp grounders. We see why the Braves are perennial winners....athletic player at 2nd, and Harris & Acuna in OF. They just scout better talent.
Several teams to make the playoffs are just so average. Its even more bothersome that Sterns made so many bad roster decisions that our team finished last and out of the playoffs! Let's hope he can make the correct decisions and fill our holes and we can be a team that can compete and actually have post season success. LGM!
Why no mention of Mauricio for 2B? He very well could have finally figured things out at the plate, so let's give him a chance to win the job, along with all the others named. Baty and Semien can be bench guys.
Also, was Stafura really worth the millions sent along with Weaver (with the year left on his contract) to Pittsburgh?
You are right. He deserves another shot. And you're also right about the Weaver deal. If it was a rental, fine. But he's under contract for another year and, as you say, they sent along money. Stafura's got a long way to go--if he ever gets there.
I think there are 2 options at second base next season. Rojas or Bichette. With the other playing 3rd base. Baty can't be trusted to be anything more than a utility player, bat off the bench type of player. And frankly, his value is based on his low salary. The more he makes in arbitration, the more likely they can find a better talent at an equal or lower price.
What they do at 2nd is wholly dependent on what they do for DH, a position they only recognize as a spot in the batting to rest some players, what they do to give protection to Soto, Bo wasn't that guy ... and everything else. And If they get a legit bat at 1B, they may be able to use a glove at 2B. Every hole that needs filling is dependent on every other hole. It's called a plan. And please, no full-time Baty at 2B. He puts on a show for a few weeks a year every year and sucks the rest of the season. Yes, call me Captain Obvious.
Sounds like it would be best for the Mets to pay Semien to go away. Money, it seems, is something they have in depth. Maybe see who becomes a free agent, or give a minor leaguer a shot.
IMO 2nd base needs to be filled by Rojas or Pitre. I doubt Voit or Stafura make it out of camp since they haven’t played AAA yet. If Baty is on the team he just needs to be a bench guy. I think Bo will opt in. Sign Sato for 1st.
Rojas has nearly 2,000 plate appearances in the minor leagues. (Carson Benge had only a little more than 1,100 in college and the minor leages.) I say we give Jefferson the first crack at 2B. We can figure out Baty (who had more tan 1,500 PA in the minors and almost as many for the Mets) later.
"When that poor defense was combined with his .620 OPS, Semien became unplayable, although he continued to get regular playing time despite his poor performance. " Quite so. The question is why did they continue to trot him out? We're told that both Stearns and Green are very smart guys. Are they? I think Rojas or Pitre should get a full shot, just like Benge and Ewing did. Keep them in even if they don't hit right away. Regarding Baty, it's very hard to know how much playing all over the place affected his hitting. I like Soto at DH, at least part of the time. If I were Stearns I'd also approach him about first base.
My question relates to the extent that the defensive metrics at 2B are tied to those at SS. In 2025 Seager had excellent numbers. In 2026 the NYM were ranked 27th at SS. I’d suggest there an infield issue at 1B, 2B, and SS for the Mets and inevitably Semien numbers can’t be isolated from the crummy numbers on either side of him. There was a broad generalized failure defensively and Semien contributed to that was was impacted by that.
Which reminds me that I think we should admit that Lindor is on the downside of his career. I'd love to be wrong.
Just a matter of time before he’s moved to 2B.
The problem is both the Mets and Semien believe he's still a power hitter, capable of slugging 25+ home runs. The number of fly balls that were caught well in front of the warning track, clearly said otherwise. Until the Mets and Marcus recognize that he's not that guy anymore and just focuses on making hard contact, the better off they'll both be. Unless he decides to pull a Cuddyer, they're stuck with each other for two more years. That being said, I think it would be wise for Andy Green to have a heart to heart talk with him about what type of ballplayer he is and wants to be, at this point in his career.
I was always a Semien fan and liked his performance in Oakland. Naturally the Mets got him as career was waning and he didn't do much. IN the last 2 months was he trying to hit fly balls all the time? Automatic outs. He never seemed to hit sharp grounders. We see why the Braves are perennial winners....athletic player at 2nd, and Harris & Acuna in OF. They just scout better talent.
Several teams to make the playoffs are just so average. Its even more bothersome that Sterns made so many bad roster decisions that our team finished last and out of the playoffs! Let's hope he can make the correct decisions and fill our holes and we can be a team that can compete and actually have post season success. LGM!
Why no mention of Mauricio for 2B? He very well could have finally figured things out at the plate, so let's give him a chance to win the job, along with all the others named. Baty and Semien can be bench guys.
Also, was Stafura really worth the millions sent along with Weaver (with the year left on his contract) to Pittsburgh?
You are right. He deserves another shot. And you're also right about the Weaver deal. If it was a rental, fine. But he's under contract for another year and, as you say, they sent along money. Stafura's got a long way to go--if he ever gets there.
I think there are 2 options at second base next season. Rojas or Bichette. With the other playing 3rd base. Baty can't be trusted to be anything more than a utility player, bat off the bench type of player. And frankly, his value is based on his low salary. The more he makes in arbitration, the more likely they can find a better talent at an equal or lower price.
What they do at 2nd is wholly dependent on what they do for DH, a position they only recognize as a spot in the batting to rest some players, what they do to give protection to Soto, Bo wasn't that guy ... and everything else. And If they get a legit bat at 1B, they may be able to use a glove at 2B. Every hole that needs filling is dependent on every other hole. It's called a plan. And please, no full-time Baty at 2B. He puts on a show for a few weeks a year every year and sucks the rest of the season. Yes, call me Captain Obvious.
Sounds like it would be best for the Mets to pay Semien to go away. Money, it seems, is something they have in depth. Maybe see who becomes a free agent, or give a minor leaguer a shot.
Pitre is also a possibility. He doesn’t have the ceiling of Rojas or Voit but he might advance more quickly.
And Baty at best is a platoon player. He hasn’t shown anything against lefthanded pitching.