13 Comments
User's avatar
harvey's avatar

I don't think Semien, Gold Glove and all, is $25 million better than having Acuno at 2B. That $$ could be better spent.

Expand full comment
Joel's avatar

You may be right. The trade only makes sense if they sign Bellinger or Tucker, which I fervently hope they do.

Expand full comment
thehorlick's avatar

locking into having a 35 year old second baseman and a 32 year old shortstop for the next 2-3 years is curious.

Expand full comment
Rich MacLeod's avatar

I think it's more about what this opening in the outfield allows them to do now vs. focusing so much on Semien himself. Time will tell, though!

Expand full comment
thehorlick's avatar

Well, there is now a new hole in leftfield that needs to be filled. Along with the hole in centerfield. and at first base. and the back-end of the bullpen. and the middle of the bullpen. and the front of the rotation. LMAO

Expand full comment
Rich MacLeod's avatar

Let’s see what they do first and judge accordingly. It’s still quite early!

Expand full comment
Joel's avatar

What is your beef with Lindor?

Expand full comment
thehorlick's avatar

lindor did not have a great season defensively (negative DRS, 60th in Outs Above Average, 15th out of all shortstops).

Expand full comment
Joel's avatar

When I watched him, which wasn't every day, I thought he was great.

Expand full comment
thehorlick's avatar

the statistics tell a different story.

Expand full comment
Raul Fernandez's avatar

Going after Bichette now doesn't make as much sense. Bichette was declining at SS. 2b would serve him better than third, I guess. Tucker and/or Bellinger seems to be another massive contract (money and length) to add to Soto, Lindor, possibly Alonso and Diaz. And this is why I love the off-season!!

Expand full comment
George Armonaitis Jr.'s avatar

Everyone keeps talking around the locker room issues last year. Hint they were there, talk about bringing in strong clubhouse guys, but not saying what the issue was. C'mon guys either tell us the whole story or none of it. Ottavino touched on issues, but... who knows if Otto is full of it or not. It is worse saying nothing and letting the public determine what they think the issues were, because right now Brandon Nimmo is getting the leader in the clubhouse cancer vote. with McNeil and Alonso also in there.

Expand full comment
Joel's avatar

Imo, we have to think they'll resign Alonso and Diaz. Besides that, given this trade, they must go hard for Bellinger or Tucker. Seems unrealistic to think they'll sign another big FA like Bregman or Bichette.

Expand full comment